
“What happens in costume stays in costume,” Ricky’s NYC says. I completely agree. When you put on what you think is the best costume ever, and combine it with several alcohol-induced beverages—forget about it. You are now the sexiest thing walking around the streets. Fangs meet fishnets, and blood is dripping on bodies. It’s a night where fantasy mixes with reality—imaginations are definitely running wild. Choose your costume this year with the top picks in shops around the city.
1. Frankie Steinz
24 Harrison Street
(between Hudson Street & Greenwich Street)
(212) 925-1373
By Appointment Only
This is my top pick for costume shops in the city. Design your own costumes with the eclectically-crazy help of Ms. Steinz herself. Her interactive website screams creativity with a dog jumping around the page and baby heads lying on the floor. Get your free quote today! You better hurry, she usually takes orders months in advance, but she does do rush orders! Order from her eBay store or choose from a wide selection of rentals. Partner up and be Cruella De Vil and a Dalmatian, or a Stove and Refrigerator. Go as a group: how about a Fruit Salad or a group of Killer Bees? You will not be dissatisfied with your costume—stars like Dolly Parton, Diana Ross, and Bill Cosby wear her outrageous designs.
2. New York Costumes
104 Fourth Avenue
(at 11th Street)
1-800-99JUMPY
Marked as New York’s biggest Halloween store, New York Costumes can pretty much guarantee you anything you are looking for. If not, special order or rent it. Don’t be overwhelmed with their website—they just want you to have endless options. After all, we can never decide if we want to be a Squawk Walker or a Winter Willie, right? What about being Amish? No problem. How about Johnny Depp? They have one kick-ass wig perfect for your pirate fantasy! Or be bad-ass, and accessorize with an armor shield and sword. Even make your pooch the most desired dog on the block—I personally enjoy the sexy School Puppy costume and the Muscle Bound Hound. Check out their website for more ideas on costumes, accessories, and decorations for your Halloween fun.
3. Masquerade Times Square Costume Shop
311 West 43rd Street
(between 8th and 9th Avenues)
(212) 247-0104
Head over to Times Square, the Mecca for everything obnoxious. Masquerade Costume Shop says they proudly “cater to Theater District regulars, local midtown denizens, party-goers from all over, and visitors from abroad and beyond.” They have your usual costumes, props, make-up, and masks—but customized fangs? How cool is that? They make them while you wait, but it’s by appointment only, so schedule now! Starting at $150 a set, anyone can take part in the sexy vampire phenomenon sweeping the nation. Thanks Mr. Pattinson! If you’re strapped on cash, DIY! They have a tab where you print a mask, cut it out, and add elastic. Become a political figure, a clown, or Jedi. See the wide variety of everything Halloween on their website.
4. Ricky’s NYC
375 Broadway
(between Franklin and White Streets)
(212) 925-5490
This year-round costume shop is located in Tribeca and has 17 temporary stores all over Manhattan for the Halloween season. Choose from thousands of costumes—adults, kids, babies, naughty, nice, pets, and even mommy-to-be! Ricky’s is known as having the “hottest, craziest, and funkiest costumes” in the city. They expect this year’s hottest sellers to be Kate Gosselin and Michelle Obama wigs, and a Bernie Madoff costume, which includes a mask and prison jumpsuit. I think the four pages of Michael Jackson items are guaranteed to be a hit. Celebrating their 20-year anniversary, Ricky’s knows how to do Halloween. Join in on their online countdown dedicated to a night of dress up, drinks, and dancing.
5. Creative Costume Company
242 W. 36th Street 8th floor
(212) 564-5552
Can’t find exactly what you’re looking for? Don’t freak out! Creative Costume Company will make it for you. Just give them your size, idea, and theme, and they will sketch up your costume and make it for you. Check out a sample from sketch to garment. You can also rent. If it doesn’t fit perfectly, they will alter it for you at no additional charge. The rental fees range from $50-$250, with a $200 deposit fee. Plus, you get to keep it for 48 hours—make your Halloween last longer! Now you can be the sports star, superstar, superhero, or sexy something all weekend!